2/24/2026REXI Legal Team
Zero Depreciation Car Insurance: An Honest Cost-Benefit Analysis
Zero Depreciation (or Nil Dep) can make the difference between getting ₹30,000 or ₹50,000 on a claim. But it adds 15–25% to your premium. Here is exactly when it makes financial sense — and when it does not.
What is Zero Dep?
In a standard insurance policy, if your car is repaired, the insurer deducts "Depreciation" on the parts replaced.
- Plastics/Rubber? 50% deduction.
- Metal? 10-50% deduction.
Zero Depreciation (Nil Dep) removes these deductions. The insurer pays for the parts in full.
The Cost Trap: Plastic vs Metal
Modern cars are mostly plastic (bumpers, headlights, sensors). If you hit a gate and break your bumper, the repair bill might be ₹20,000.
- Standard Policy: Insurer says bumper is plastic, so 50% depreciation. They pay ₹10,000. You pay ₹10,000 + deductible.
- Zero Dep Policy: Insurer pays ₹20,000. You pay only the deductible (usually ₹1,000).
When is it Worth It?
| Car Age | Recommendation | Why? |
|---|---|---|
| 0-3 Years | Mandatory | Most accidents happen in the early years; parts are expensive. |
| 3-5 Years | Recommended | Premium for Zero Dep is lower now, but protection is high. |
| 5-7 Years | Optional | Only if parts for your car are hard to find or very expensive. |
| 7+ Years | Not Worth It | Most insurers won't even offer it; its cost outweighs the benefit. |
3 Hidden Limits of Zero Dep
- 1Claim Count: Most policies only allow 2 Zero Dep claims per year. The 3rd claim will be processed with normal depreciation.
- 2Compulsory Deductible: You still have to pay ₹1,000 - ₹2,000 for every claim. Zero Dep is not "free" insurance.
- 3Consumables: Zero dep covers the parts, but not the nuts, bolts, engine oil, or coolant used. You need a separate "Consumables Cover" for that.
---
Conclusion
If your car is under 5 years old, Zero Dep is a no-brainer. It costs maybe ₹2,000 extra but saves you ₹20,000 in a single accident.